The party game Top That Toast consists of two decks of cards: 50 Tone Cards and 200 Topic Cards. All players begin the game by drawing 5 Topic Cards. The oldest player in the group begins as the Facilitoaster.
The Facilitoaster begins the round by drawing a Tone Card; which determines the tone or style of the toast (some examples include Humor; Sincere; Tearjerker; and Roast). All other players respond by submitting a Topic Card; face-down on the table. The Facilitoaster then reads the Topic Cards aloud and chooses the Topic Card that; in his or her opinion; best matches the Tone Card and deserves to be toasted. The player who submitted that Topic Card then delivers a toast and thereby wins a Tone Card for that round.
There are additional competitive aspects of the game. In the event that 2 or more of the same Topic Card is submitted in a round; the Facilitoaster has the option to call for a Toast Off; where the players who submitted the same Topic Card each give a toast. The Facilitoaster will award the Tone Card to the player who gave the best toast.
When the Top That Toast Tone Card is drawn; each player will give a toast based on the Topic Card that is selected by the Facilitoaster. Once all toasts are completed; the Facilitoaster chooses which player is awarded the Tone Card.
After each round; the role of the Facilitoaster rotates around the table. Once a player has won a pre-determined number of Tone Cards; that player wins the game!
